MARKETING
Storytelling Helps in B2B Product Marketing, Too
Product differentiation theory goes back 90 years to economist Edward Hastings Chamberlin’s book Theory of Monopolistic Competition.
Let me save you the read and share his view on product or service differentiation, which is still in use today:
A general class of product is differentiated if any significant basis exists for distinguishing the goods (or services) of one seller from those of another. Such as basis may be real or fancied, so long as it is of any importance whatever to buyers and leads to a preference for one variety of the product over another.
He goes on to describe three differentiation categories that are very relevant to product marketing: vertical, horizontal, and mixed.
Many marketers, including me, say differentiation is one of the most difficult things to get right – and very few nail it. But here’s the good news: Storytelling (once again) comes to the rescue.
Before I explain how, let’s look at why marketers struggle so much with differentiation.
Many marketers say product differentiation is one of the most difficult things to get right – and few nail it, says @Robert_Rose via @CMIContent. #ProductMarketing Click To Tweet
Why product differentiation in marketing is so difficult
It’s easy to see the differentiation buckets (vertical, horizontal, and mixed) and say, “OK, great, I’ll focus on that one.” But picking one can be extraordinarily difficult.
Customers are irrational. Getting customers to identify how they make decisions is almost impossible, especially for complex purchases. Contextual conditions, emotions, and other factors, including memory, can inhibit marketers from choosing the correct horizontal or vertical differentiators.
Some competitors aren’t competitors. Your company’s top competitors are often not the best comparison. Nor can you differentiate your brand against perceived competitors. New and less-clear markets are particularly susceptible to this. I hear tech startups say, “We’re in a category all by ourselves.” My response is, “That’s not a good thing.” It’s hard to find differentiation if there’s nothing to differentiate against.
Things change quickly. Continually monitoring customers and going deeper into competitive, contextual, and other market differentiation is difficult. Today’s market moves quickly. It can often be faster to throw differentiators against the wall and see what sticks.
Then, the categories themselves involve challenges.
Vertical differentiation depends on the customer’s hierarchy. In this category, differences among products are objective. Customers identify discernable options and rank the products’ quality and prices. They choose based on their hierarchy of highest to lowest quality. For example, a customer picks an Apple computer because the brand is known for high-quality products. Or someone selects a frozen pizza because its calorie count is the lowest. Perhaps the buyer chooses a known brand over an unknown brand.
An old saying in the consulting industry, “Nobody got fired for hiring IBM,” is an example of vertical differentiation.
Horizontal differentiation depends on customer feelings. Horizontal product differences are subjective because no objective ranking can distinguish the “best.” Customers choose based on what they like best at that moment. Someone who prefers vanilla chooses a shake of that flavor rather than a chocolate one. An iPhone customer picks the purple model because that’s their favorite color. Or the company selects an enterprise software package because your CEO liked that salesperson the best.
Mixed differentiation comes into play on complex purchases. More considered or complex purchases usually fall into the mixed differentiation category. Customers use vertical and horizontal differentiation in varying combinations. For example, a couple planning to buy a new car considers many objective metrics (gas mileage and safety rankings) and subjective ones (friendliness of sales staff) when deciding among brands.
But defaulting to mixed messaging rarely works
Each differentiation approach has a different focus in product marketing. In vertical differentiation, marketers focus on the features customers rank as super important. That could be price, bells and whistles, or anything that distinguishes the product in the customer’s mind.
On the other hand, horizontal differentiation revolves around letting the buyer know that “people just like you” make this choice. It’s designed to help the customer make a decision.
For example, a restaurant packages several of its menu items into a combo and denotes, “People with a big appetite prefer this option.” The restaurant built in differentiation even though the food items also can be sold separately. An online store could help the buyer decide by showcasing variety: “Here’s a rainbow of colors for your selection.” Or it might suggest a product with “Buyers like you purchased this item.”
Mixed differentiation balances both horizontal and vertical considerations.
Marketers often default to mixed differentiation because they don’t understand how they should differentiate their product market. They either don’t understand the customer well enough to know the ranked preferences or think they must invent differences because they offer a commoditized product.
Remember the failed “phablet”? Devices sized between a phone and a tablet sprang up over a decade ago. While larger phones and smaller tablets ultimately succeeded in the marketplace, the phablet moniker didn’t.
Marketers sometimes use mixed differentiation to get the best of both worlds. You see it in phrasing such as:
- Efficiently unlock high performance
- Fully integrated and modular
- Transform your business while being able to focus on the basics
- Powerfully complex and intuitive to use
- Benefit from data-driven creativity (my new favorite).
This occasionally confusing differentiation shows up even in the most modern companies and marketing.
OpenAI’s product page, for example, features the headline “Transforming work and creativity with AI.” Adjacent to that header is the text, “Our API platform offers our latest models and guides for safety best practices.”
Source: OpenAI
I don’t want to pick on the copywriting team, but I wonder why they separate work and creativity. Are they different? Is it important to transform them separately? Do the writers believe their customers rank those elements as most important? Or are the writers taking a horizontal approach to showcase AI’s variety of benefits?
In the page copy, they focus more on vertical differentiation by highlighting the qualitative features of their API platform to differentiate it from other generative AI products. But do they succeed?
Therein lies an inherent challenge with mixed differentiation – intentional or otherwise. It often amounts to just clever ways not to say much at all.
Storytelling can help you differentiate
Storytelling often shows up in content and brand marketing, where it lets you tell customer experiences more effectively or relate your brand’s origin story.
But storytelling also works to position product marketing differentiation. When done well, a great story connects and aligns audiences to bigger themes or points of view. It aligns those views with the marketer’s desired differentiators. Stories can help people care about things they didn’t know they cared about.
Storytelling in #ProductMarketing can help people care about things they didn’t realize they cared about, says @Robert_Rose via @CMIContent. #Content Click To Tweet
Tech vendor SAP’s nine-part podcast series Searching for Salai is a great example. The content campaign supported the launch of a product and service solution called Leonardo, which combined AI technology, blockchain, and the Internet of Things.
The podcast told the story of a time-traveling art history buff’s investigation into (and an interview with) a mysterious person who may be the long-time apprentice of Leonardo DaVinci. The time traveler demonstrates how innovation arises from the combination of technology, data, and people.
Can you guess which solution differentiators SAP wanted to focus on in their marketing for Leonardo?
Storytelling gives you the best of both worlds (irony duly noted). It lets you choose how to differentiate while helping you convince your customer to care about your differentiators.
Classic product differentiation is about trying to meet customers’ prioritized preferences. Great storytelling helps you create preferences that customers will prioritize.
It’s your story. Tell it well.
Cover image by Joseph Kalinowski/Content Marketing Institute
MARKETING
Trends in Content Localization – Moz
Multinational fast food chains are one of the best-known examples of recognizing that product menus may sometimes have to change significantly to serve distinct audiences. The above video is just a short run-through of the same business selling smokehouse burgers, kofta, paneer, and rice bowls in an effort to appeal to people in a variety of places. I can’t personally judge the validity of these representations, but what I can see is that, in such cases, you don’t merely localize your content but the products on which your content is founded.
Sometimes, even the branding of businesses is different around the world; what we call Burger King in America is Hungry Jack’s in Australia, Lays potato chips here are Sabritas in Mexico, and DiGiorno frozen pizza is familiar in the US, but Canada knows it as Delissio.
Tales of product tailoring failures often become famous, likely because some of them may seem humorous from a distance, but cultural sensitivity should always be taken seriously. If a brand you are marketing is on its way to becoming a large global seller, the best insurance against reputation damage and revenue loss as a result of cultural insensitivity is to employ regional and cultural experts whose first-hand and lived experiences can steward the organization in acting with awareness and respect.
MARKETING
How AI Is Redefining Startup GTM Strategy
MARKETING
More promotions and more layoffs
For martech professionals salaries are good and promotions are coming faster, unfortunately, layoffs are coming faster, too. That’s according to the just-released 2024 Martech Salary and Career Survey. Another very unfortunate finding: The median salary of women below the C-suite level is 35% less than what men earn.
The last year saw many different economic trends, some at odds with each other. Although unemployment remained very low overall and the economy grew, some businesses — especially those in technology and media — cut both jobs and spending. Reasons cited for the cuts include during the early years of the pandemic, higher interest rates and corporate greed.
Dig deeper: How to overcome marketing budget cuts and hiring freezes
Be that as it may, for the employed it remains a good time to be a martech professional. Salaries remain lucrative compared to many other professions, with an overall median salary of $128,643.
Here are the median salaries by role:
- Senior management $199,653
- Director $157,776
- Manager $99,510
- Staff $89,126
Senior managers make more than twice what staff make. Directors and up had a $163,395 median salary compared to manager/staff roles, where the median was $94,818.
One-third of those surveyed said they were promoted in the last 12 months, a finding that was nearly equal among director+ (32%) and managers and staff (30%).
Extend the time frame to two years, and nearly three-quarters of director+ respondents say they received a promotion, while the same can be said for two-thirds of manager and staff respondents.
Dig deeper: Skills-based hiring for modern marketing teams
Employee turnover
In 2023, we asked survey respondents if they noticed an increase in employee churn and whether they would classify that churn as a “moderate” or “significant” increase. For 2024, given the attention on cost reductions and layoffs, we asked if the churn they witnessed was “voluntary” (e.g., people leaving for another role) or “involuntary” (e.g., a layoff or dismissal). More than half of the marketing technology professionals said churn increased in the last year. Nearly one-third classified most of the churn as “involuntary.”
Men and Women
This year, instead of using average salary figures, we used the median figures to lessen the impact of outliers in the salary data. As a result, the gap between salaries for men and women is even more glaring than it was previously.
In last year’s report, men earned an average of 24% more than women. This year the median salary of men is 35% more than the median salary of women. That is until you get to the upper echelons. Women at director and up earned 5% more than men.
Methodology
The 2024 MarTech Salary and Career Survey is a joint project of MarTech.org and chiefmartec.com. We surveyed 305 marketers between December 2023 and February 2024; 297 of those provided salary information. Nearly 63% (191) of respondents live in North America; 16% (50) live in Western Europe. The conclusions in this report are limited to responses from those individuals only. Other regions were excluded due to the limited number of respondents.
Download your copy of the 2024 MarTech Salary and Career Survey here. No registration is required.
Get MarTech! Daily. Free. In your inbox.
-
SEO6 days ago
Contact Us Page Examples: 44 Designs For Inspiration
-
SEO6 days ago
Google’s Advice For Ranking: Stop Showing
-
SEARCHENGINES6 days ago
Daily Search Forum Recap: March 22, 2024
-
WORDPRESS6 days ago
WordPress Block Themes Explained in 250 Seconds – WordPress.com News
-
PPC7 days ago
The 8 Best Lead Generation Ideas from Marketing Experts
-
SEO6 days ago
Save Time With Keywords Explorer Tool
-
MARKETING7 days ago
Local Search Developments from Q1 2024
-
PPC6 days ago
Mastering Lead Generation in Paid Search Advertising