In what could be a significant move in the broader regulation of the digital eco-sphere, the Australian Government has announced that it’s looking to provide financial assistance to struggling local news organizations by implementing a new, mandatory code of conduct which would require Google and Facebook to share any revenue they generate as a result of news content with the relevant publishers of such material.
As per Australian Treasurer Josh Frydenberg:
“The Government has instructed the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) to develop a mandatory code to address commercial arrangements between digital platforms and news media businesses. Among the elements the code will cover include the sharing of data, ranking and display of news content and the monetization and the sharing of revenue generated from news.”
Treasurer Frydenberg notes that the Australian media sector was already under significant pressure, but that’s now been “exacerbated by a sharp decline in advertising revenue driven by coronavirus”. This, along with inaction from the digital giants in working to provide a more adequate process of compensation for publishers, has prompted the Government to act.
The announcement stems from the ACCC’s 600+ page “Digital Platforms Inquiry” report which was released in June last year. The report covers all aspects of the online media industry, and concerns relating to data-sharing, misinformation, and consumer understanding of how digital platforms operate.
The report breaks down the shifting media landscape, and how Google and Facebook have come to dominate the local advertising market, at the expense, in particular, of print media.
That imbalance prompted the Government to seek alternatives, and with a significant amount of Google and Facebook’s content coming from news publishers, a case can be made for a more mutually beneficial arrangement between them.
As per the report:
“The content produced by news media businesses is also important to digital platforms. For example, between 8 and 14 per cent of Google search results trigger a “Top Stories” result, which typically includes reports from news media websites including niche publications or blogs.”
That said, the ACCC also notes that:
“Google and Facebook each appear to be more important to the major news media businesses than any one news media business is to Google or Facebook.”
That gives the online giants significant power, which is why the Government is now seeking to step in and facilitate an alternative arrangement.
Among the many recommendations, the ACCC calls for both Google and Facebook to:
- Within the limits of data protection and privacy laws, share data with media businesses about users’ consumption of the media business’ news content on the digital platform’s service(s). For example, data collected by Facebook on its platform, or Google on news content published in the AMP format and served from Google’s cache, derived from news content provided by media businesses.
- Give media businesses early warning of significant changes to the ranking or display of news that would be reasonably likely to affect the referral traffic of media businesses.
- Ensure that the digital platform’s actions will not impede news media businesses’ opportunities to appropriately monetize their content on the digital platform’s sites or apps, or on the media businesses’ own sites or apps.
- Where the digital platform obtains value directly or indirectly from content produced by news media businesses, fairly negotiate with news media businesses as to how that revenue should be shared, or how the news media businesses should be compensated.
The final point is the key focus here, though the advanced warning of any algorithm shifts is also significant.
Within its additional notes, the ACCC also calls for the parties to negotiate such deals among themselves:
“The ACCC considers that determining such issues by commercial negotiation, taking into account the unique nature of each commercial relationship, is more appropriate than having a regulator determine aspects of the relationship such as an appropriate price or snippet length.”
Initially, on the official release of the report in December, the Australian Government gave Google and Facebook eleven months to respond to its request for the development of voluntary codes to address these concerns, but as noted, with the COVID-19 pandemic further reducing the capacity for news outlets to generate revenue through traditional means, and a lack of engagement from the online giants with respect to the development of these agreements, the government is now looking to take action, and legislate official rules on news revenue sharing.
Various nations have attempted to implement similar regulation, with less than desirable results.
Last year, France implemented its ‘neighboring rights’ copyright laws, which stipulate that media firms be adequately compensated when their content is used on websites, including in search engine results and on social media platforms. Google responded by saying that it wouldn’t ‘pay for links’, instead setting up an alternate process which meant that it would only display articles, images and videos in search results from media companies that had explicitly allowed it to use such for free. The dispute is still ongoing as to how to resolve the stand-off.
Spain, meanwhile, implemented its own laws around such usage back in 2014, which essentially required news aggregators to pay for a license to use news content. As a result, Google shut down Google News in Spain at the end of 2014, a move that reportedly saw many publishers experience double-digit drops in web traffic.
Given the precedent, it’ll be interesting to see what the outcome is in the Australian market. Based on past history, and its specific inaction in response to the Australian Government’s initial call for negotiation, there’s nothing to indicate that Google will be looking to alter its stance.
If anything, it seems that Google has sought to make a clear example of such cases – if Google negotiates, and allows other nations and publishers to see that such agreements are possible, that could end up costing it billions in fees around the world. As such, in all likelihood, neither Google nor Facebook will be intending to make a switch in their approaches, and will instead seek to alter their processes in accordance with revised local laws.
That could lead to significant changes in the way content is displayed on the digital giants, which, if anything, will only take traffic away from the traditional media players, and provide more instead to less mainstream outlets.
The outcome then could be less reliable news coverage overall – which is another key area of concern raised by the ACCC’s report. As such, the initiative is interesting, and the logic behind the push has merit. But enforcement looks set to remain problematic.
The Australian Government plans to have a draft mandatory code by the end of July, with a final code to be settled soon thereafter.
New Screenshots Highlight How Snapchat’s Coming ‘Family Center’ Will Work
Snapchat’s parental control options look close to launch, with new screenshots based on back-end code showing how Snap’s coming ‘Family Center’ will look in the app.
As you can see in these images, shared by app intelligence company Watchful (via TechCrunch), the Family Center will enable parents to see who their child is engaging with in the app, along with who they’ve added, who they’re following, etc.
That could provide a new level of assurance for parents – though it could also be problematic for Snap, which has become a key resource for more private, intimate connection, with its anti-public posting ethos, and disappearing messages, helping to cement its place as an alternative to other social apps.
That’s really how Snap has embedded its niche. While other apps are about broadcasting your life to the wider world, Snap is about connecting with a small group of friends, where you can share your more private, secret thoughts, without concern of them living on forever, and coming back to bite you at a later stage.
That also, of course, means that more questionable, dangerous communications are happening in the app. Various reports have investigated how Snap is used for sending lewd messages, and arranging hook-ups, while drug dealers reportedly now use Snap to organize meet-ups and sales.
Which, of course, is why parents will be keen to get more insight into such, but I can’t imagine Snap users will be so welcoming of an intrusive tool in this respect.
But if parents know that it exists, they may have to, and that could be problematic for Snap. Teen users will need to accept their parents’ invitation to enable Family Center monitoring, but you can see how this could become an issue for many younger users in the app.
Still, the protective benefits may well be worth it, with random hook-ups and other engagements posing significant risks. And with kids as young as 13 able to create a Snapchat account, there are many vulnerable youngsters engaging in the app.
But it could reduce Snap’s appeal, as more parents become aware of the tool.
Snapchat hasn’t provided any further insight into the new Family Center, or when it will be released, but it looks close to launch based on these images.
How is the Blockchain Shaping the Digital Marketing Automation Tools?
Google Displays Out Of Stock For Items Using Back Order Value In Structured Data
Tiny Tina’s Wonderlands: Glutton’s Gamble is Out Now for Xbox One and Xbox Series X|S
New Screenshots Highlight How Snapchat’s Coming ‘Family Center’ Will Work
LinkedIn Updates Professional Community Policies to Better Reflect What’s Not Allowed in the App
Google Dedicated Local Ad Pack
The Body Bugs are Coming for You – Free Today on Xbox
Daily Search Forum Recap: May 20, 2022
How Data Is Reshaping The SEO & Digital Marketer’s Landscape
How TikTok Creators Redefined Influence [Infographic]
LinkedIn Adds Live Captions for Audio Events, Custom URL Listings on Creator Profiles
LinkedIn Shares New Insights into the Brand Benefits of Adopting Sustainability Best Practices [Infographic]
Six Ways to Adjust Google Ads to Save Budget
Google Search With Larger Images Again On Desktop Results
Daily Search Forum Recap: May 2, 2022
How Does Google Multisearch Affect SEO?
Where To Invest In SEO For Maximum Impact
How to Write the Perfect Page Title With SEO in Mind
Start an Affiliate Marketing Side Hustle to Bring in Passive Income
Google Says You Can Use Hashtags In Meta Descriptions
SEARCHENGINES5 days ago
Google Search Console Performance Reports Logs Additional Desktop Features
PPC4 days ago
Three Key Moments You Can’t Miss at Hero Conf London 2022
SEO5 days ago
Google Ads Makes Automation Easier With Scripts Updates
MARKETING4 days ago
What is Conversation Intelligence and Facts you didnt know About the Software?