SEARCHENGINES

Google Says AI Content Is Not By Default Well Received By Its Algorithms

Published

1 year ago

July 20, 2023

Danny Sullivan, Google’s Search Liaison, responded to Vox Media’s claim that AI content is currently “well-received by search engines.” Sullivan said, “It’s still not correct that AI content will be “well-received by search engines,” at least for us.”

Sullivan went on to explain on Twitter that “There’s lots of AI content on the web that doesn’t rank well and hence isn’t well received” by Google Search. “AI content has no magic ranking powers,” Sullivan said.

Only “if content is helpful, then it might succeed,” but not because AI wrote it does it mean the content is helpful.

Sullivan wrote to the author, “FYI about this part: “he’s learned that AI content ‘will, at least for the moment, be well-received by search engines’.” This isn’t correct. Our systems are looking at the helpfulness of content, rather than how it is produced,” Danny Sullivan clarified.

“We’d encourage publishers, however they produce content, to ensure they’re making it for people-first,” he added. “Producing a lot of content with the primary purpose of ranking in search, rather than for people, should be avoided. Sites producing a lot of unhelpful content not intended for people-first may find all of their content less likely to be successful with search,” he said.

Here are those tweets:

It’s still not correct that AI content will be “well-received by search engines,” at least for us. There’s lots of AI content on the web that doesn’t rank well and hence isn’t well received. AI content has no magic ranking powers. If *content* is helpful, then it might succeed.

— Google SearchLiaison (@searchliaison) July 18, 2023

To be fair, I didn’t read Peter Kafka’s line as saying all AI-content is received well by Google Search. Just that Google Search is open to saying AI-content can rank well if it is quality.

As Google’s Sullivan wrote before on explaining the who, how and why on AI content that if you do all of that and the content is generated to help people, then it might do well. But if you are using AI to write content to just rank in search, then it might not do so well.

In any event, I think this is just a matter of Sullivan trying to clarify some confusion but I don’t know if the article is saying what some are thinking it is saying. No, Google does not rank AI-generated content better because it was written by AI.

Here is the debate on that part, but it is just for fun:

Peter! I (because I’m a person, not a bot), don’t know that it’s obvious to everyone. That’s why I keep emphasizing it’s not about whether content is AI generated, staff writer generated, freelance generate or the exact production method but rather the purpose and quality….

— Google SearchLiaison (@searchliaison) July 18, 2023

And no, we didn’t take any specific action on that particular article. Why it no longer ranks as well is entirely down to our automated systems that look at many different factors. Rankings change all the time.

— Google SearchLiaison (@searchliaison) July 18, 2023

Danny wanted to point out this clarification:

To be clear, I was explaining that AI content has no special ranking powers and that clearly lots of it doesn’t rank. It’s not about how content is generated. It’s about the purpose and quality of the content. Pretty much what we said here: https://t.co/w4LGtiJRXI

— Google SearchLiaison (@searchliaison) July 19, 2023

Forum discussion at Twitter.

Update: Later today the NY Times wrote Google Tests A.I. Tool That Is Able to Write News Articles – here is Google’s response:

Check out our statement on the @nytimes story about potential AI-enabled tools for news publishers:

In partnership with news publishers, especially smaller publishers, we’re in the earliest stages of exploring ideas to potentially provide AI-enabled tools to help journalists…

— Google Communications (@Google_Comms) July 20, 2023

Source link

Related Topics:algorithms Content default Google Received searchengine

Up Next

Expect A Confirm Google Algorithm Update This Summer

Don't Miss

Bing Chat Gets Visual Search

SEARCHENGINES

Daily Search Forum Recap: July 19, 2024

Published

10 hours ago

July 19, 2024

Entireweb News Bot

Here is a recap of what happened in the search forums today, through the eyes of the Search Engine Roundtable and other search forums on the web.

Google’s URL shortener will stop working in a year and all those billions of links / redirects will vanish. Google says ccTLDs do help a little for ranking. Google gave advice on how to know if your SEO team is doing good. Google Merchant Center Next now supports supplemental feeds. Google local lets you search by product with your camera. And I posted the weekly SEO video recap.

Search Engine Roundtable Stories:

Billions Of Google goo.gl URLs Will No Longer Work

Google announced that it will stop serving the Google URL Shortener, so any URL that was set up to redirect using goo.gl, which Google stopped supporting adding new ones back in 2019, will also stop serving.

Google’s On Knowing If Your SEO Team Is Doing Their Job

Google’s John Mueller laid out a few ways to determine if your SEO team is doing the actual work they promised to deliver. While trusting your SEO team is important, John said you can also do the following to ensure the SEO team is doing their job.

Google Merchant Center Next Gains Support For Supplemental Feeds

Google Merchant Center Next now finally supports supplemental feed/source support. Google promised us this would come early this year, but it didn’t happen until early Q3 of 2024. That being said, feed rules still do not seem to be supported yet by Google Merchant Center Next and that was also promised by now.

Google: ccTLDs & Language Do Help You Rank A Little Better In Local Country Region

Gary Illyes from Google said in the latest Google SEO office hours that using a ccTLD and the localized language on your page and website does help you rank a little better in the localized/regional version of Google. So if you want to rank better in Google in Korea, using a ccTLd such as .kr helps a little and using Korean text on your page helps even more.

Google Local Panel: Search Products With Camera

Google is testing showing a button in some local panels, some Google Business Profiles, that reads “Search Products With Camera.” This seems to be related to Google Lens and the new multisearch features.

Search News Buzz Video Recap: Google Core Update Coming, Ranking Volatility, Bye Search Notes, AI Overviews, Ads & More

Google said that the next Google core update should be coming in the coming weeks. Google had some search ranking volatility, an unconfirmed Google update, around July 18th. Google said it will host more creator…

Google Monetization Vest Found At Goodwill Store

Nick Turner, a Senior technology editor at Bloomberg, shared a photo of his “amazing find” at the local Goodwill store. It is a Google vest that says “MONETIZATION” on the back.

Other Great Search Threads:

Search Engine Land Stories:

Feedback:

Have feedback on this daily recap; let me know on Twitter @rustybrick or @seroundtable, on Threads, Mastodon and Bluesky and you can follow us on Facebook and on Google News and make sure to subscribe to the YouTube channel, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Google Podcasts or just contact us the old fashion way.

Source link

SEARCHENGINES

Daily Search Forum Recap: July 18, 2024

Published

1 day ago

July 18, 2024

Entireweb News Bot

Here is a recap of what happened in the search forums today, through the eyes of the Search Engine Roundtable and other search forums on the web.

We’re seeing more Google Search ranking volatility, is this a sign of the core update coming? Google is testing AI Overviews on by default in the UK, even on some Workspace accounts. Google Merchant Center Next is coming to all merchants now. Google’s site reputation abuse policy forced a public company to lower earnings forecasts. Google is testing bolding the query in the search box when unselected.

Search Engine Roundtable Stories:

Google Search Ranking Algorithm Volatility – July 18th

We may be seeing the start of a Google Search ranking algorithm update, as I am starting to see volatility spiking in the Google Search results and a spike in chatter within the SEO community. I know we are expecting the next core update to touch down in the coming weeks, so maybe Google is testing/evaluating something now?

Google Tests AI Overviews In Workspace Accounts In The UK

Google AI Overviews are only really live in the United States, for personal Google accounts (not Workspace accounts) and on Chrome browsers. Well, Google seems to be showing AI Overviews to some Workspace accounts in the UK.

Google Merchant Center Next Coming To All Merchants

Google announced that Google Merchant Center Next, the updated version of Google Merchant Center it announced at Google Marketing Live in 2023, is now coming to all merchants this month. Google has already begun notifying merchants and advertisers of this via email and will continue to do so over the month.

Google’s Site Reputation Abuse Update Leads Gaming Affiliate To Reduce Financial Forecast

Catena Media, a publicly-traded online gambling information company, issued their Q2 earnings update a couple of weeks ago, saying they have reduced its revenues forecast due to the Google Site reputation abuse policy update.

Google Bolding Query In Search Box When Cursor Out Of Search Box

Google is testing bolding the query in the search box when you click your cursor outside of the search box, otherwise the query is in normal plain font text. This is a weird one – don’t you think?

Doogler Google Office Bed

Here is a photo of a Doogler, Google dog, at the Google Dublin office in a dog bed – a Google dog bed. The dog looks a bit tired and for some reason is lying near the bed and not on the bed.

Other Great Search Threads:

Search Engine Land Stories:

Feedback:

Source link

SEARCHENGINES

Daily Search Forum Recap: July 17, 2024

Published

3 days ago

July 17, 2024

Entireweb News Bot

Here is a recap of what happened in the search forums today, through the eyes of the Search Engine Roundtable and other search forums on the web.

Google has finally ended its labs experiment for Search Notes. Google Knowledge Panels tests showing store rating reviews. Google tests renaming short videos to quick takes. Google Ads in Japan changed the term brand match to intent match. Google is testing query refinements under the ad carousel.

Search Engine Roundtable Stories:

Google Search Notes Finally To End

There was a lot of speculation that Google would remove the Search Notes feature from the Google Search labs results last May after living past its official end date of December 2023. Well, Google told 9to5Google that Notes on Search and Discover is finally going away.

Google Ads Changed Broad Match To Intent Match In Japan

Google Ads has changed what they call broad match to intent match in Japan. So now it is called (Intent Match), it was called (Partial Match).

Google Knowledge Panels Tests Store Ratings Reviews

Google is testing showing store ratings review stars in the knowledge panels for some retail stores. Clicking on the stars will take you into the Google Store Rating panel.

Google Tests Renaming Short Videos To Quick Takes

Google is testing renaming the short videos carousel to quick takes in the Google Search results. Short videos are quick videos Google surfaces in its search results from YouTube, Instagram, TikTok, Facebook and other sources and now Google is testing naming them “Quick Takes.”

Google Ads Query Refinements Under Ad Carousel

Google seems to be testing a query refinement ad option. Where Google is showing other search queries related to the ads it is showing under a sponsored ad carousel in the search results.

Google Paris France Olympics Signage Adapted

In April, we covered the prep the Google Paris, France office put together for the upcoming Olympics events by dressing up its lobby signage in Olympic sports. Well, the sign changed a bit. Here is a more recent photo I found on Instagram.