SEARCHENGINES
Google Manual Actions Backlogged & Delayed Responses

Danny Sullivan of Google confirmed on Twitter that there is or was a backlog of manual actions issued by Google. Google has been slow and delayed in responding to those manual actions but is working through the backlog.
Danny said “we apologize for the delay in processing the reconsideration. We’ve had a backlog & now cleared the action.”
Here is that tweet:
The manual action was not a punishment for what you write about. It was solely for unnatural linking & again, had no impact on your ranking. We apologize for the delay in processing the reconsideration. We’ve had a backlog & now cleared the action. Your links pass trust again…
— Danny Sullivan (@dannysullivan) January 11, 2022
There are others with similar issues, hence the backlog:
“Delayed” is being quite kind. See date. pic.twitter.com/UKYqLvkGy2
— Rob P (@MrRobzilla) January 11, 2022
Now, this case is interesting in that this publisher was so upset about its Google rankings, it made a huge amount of noise. That noise got Google to respond saying that the manual action was not hurting the site’s rankings but it devalued the links it had on its outbound links. It obviously was caught for allegedly linking out for pay or other link schemes. Specifically the Unnatural links from your site manual action:
Google has detected a pattern of unnatural artificial, deceptive, or manipulative outbound links on your site. Buying links or participating in link schemes in order to manipulate PageRank is a violation of Google’s Webmaster Guidelines.
Google stopped this site from passing link value externally.
That being said, here is the full response from Danny about this case:
The manual action was not due to your journalism. It was solely for unnatural links. It was issued in mid-Dec. 2020 (not in November) and, as explained to you through Search Console, had no impact on your ranking…
— Danny Sullivan (@dannysullivan) January 11, 2022
The manual action was not a punishment for what you write about. It was solely for unnatural linking & again, had no impact on your ranking. We apologize for the delay in processing the reconsideration. We’ve had a backlog & now cleared the action. Your links pass trust again…
— Danny Sullivan (@dannysullivan) January 11, 2022
We had a core update in Dec. 2020, and sometimes that can cause traffic changes, including for Discover. Our advice about core updates is here: https://t.co/nF7Ashb3Zk
— Danny Sullivan (@dannysullivan) January 11, 2022
Click through to the original tweet to see the full complaint.
So the only thing new in this story is that Google is delayed for processing manual actions. The specific manual action is not new, Google can prevent sites from passing link value (since before 2012) and before that, even before Google had manual actions. And yes, loud people sometimes can catch Google’s attention but will it matter?
Forum discussion at Twitter.
SEARCHENGINES
February 4th Google Search Ranking Algorithm Update

There may have been another unconfirmed Google search ranking algorithm update – this one also on the weekend, around February 4th, maybe kicking off on February 3rd. I am seeing signs from both chatter within the SEO community, and also, some of the tools are showing big swings around February 4th.
The previous updates we reported about was an unconfirmed update around January 26th, then on January 18th, then January 14th – you can see the full list over here.
SEO Chatter
Let’s start by looking at some of the chatter within the SEO community. There is chatter both at WebmasterWorld and here in the comments areas:
Global site traffic continued firm all day Thursday for me and ended at 140.3%. Today has started ok for a Friday.
Seeing some sharp increase in traffic as well. Tech based sites are performing really well. Around 40% increase overall. Although a good share of Chinese bot like traffic is also present.
So, my site got a lovely boost a couple of weeks ago. Keywords I hadn’t ranked for in years plus some I had never ranked for particularly well were appearing. Two weeks later and google have yanked the rug out from under me again. A keywod I was on page 1 for is now bottom of page 4. Another that I was page 1 for – page 8 now.
I’m seeing ranking hold relatively steady, but traffic has been much worse this week. The previous two weeks were unusually high though. Yesterday search was down 17% and the day before that it was flat, but traffic to my home page has dropped considerably again. Most of the decline is USA traffic
Feels like Google released another update on Saturday 4th, no?
I noticed big changes on all my websites around 4 pm GMT onwards.
Massive volatility spotted. Seeing crazy fluctuations in rankings too.
Maybe a G Update is just around the corner?
Got hammered yesterday – almost as bad as any core update.
The fluctuation that started 24-36 hours ago is increasing gradually.
Traffic was up this morning, up until 6am UK time, then zero traffic for 4 hours. 4 hours?? How is that even possible if throttling isn’t the case?
All this chatter was between February 3rd and February 5th.
Google Tracking Tools
Here are what the tracking tool are showing:
Have you seen any big swings in rankings or traffic with your site since the weekend?
Here’s the product review site that surged on 1/26 like others I saw. It reversed on 2/3… The other I shared remains up. Again, whatever Google is pushing is impacting some product review sites heavily. It’s like they creep in/out of the gray area for a short time & surge/drop: pic.twitter.com/nUd6M0JgGc
— Glenn Gabe (@glenngabe) February 6, 2023
Forum discussion at WebmasterWorld.
SEARCHENGINES
Jeff Ferguson On Issues With SEO Studies & Ranking Factor Studies

In part one, we go through Jeff Ferguson’s long history in search marketing. In part two, we pick up with him starting his own agency. Then in part three we talk about the state of SEO studies.
In short, he goes off on his rant on SEO studies done on ranking factors and other areas. In short, he was not a fan of those studies and he wrote a lot about how they were done wrong. He wasn’t saying the intent was wrong, the companies that made these studies really wanted to help. But doing ranking factor studies are just too hard and really hard to prove.
Of course, it ruffled a lot of feathers in the SEO community. But he goes through more on why he did what he did and what he wanted to get out of it.
You can learn more about Jeff Ferguson at Amplitude Digital and follow him on Twitter @CountXero.
You can subscribe to our YouTube channel by clicking here so you don’t miss the next vlog where I interviews. I do have a nice lineup of interviews scheduled with SEOs and SEMS, many of which you don’t want to miss – and I promise to continue to make these vlogs better over time. If you want to be interviewed, please fill out this form with your details.
Forum discussion at YouTube.
SEARCHENGINES
Apple Maps Street View Camera Backpack

Here is a photo of some guy walking around Israel with an Apple Maps street view backpack. It was captured by Hillel Fuld the other day and posted on Twitter.
Google has its own street view backpack, which is more impressive to look at.
This post is part of our daily Search Photo of the Day column, where we find fun and interesting photos related to the search industry and share them with our readers.
-
SEARCHENGINES5 days ago
Helpful Content & Link Spam Update Done, SEO, Search Console & More
-
NEWS5 days ago
OpenAI Introduces ChatGPT Plus with Monthly Subscription of $20
-
PPC6 days ago
Why (& How) to Set Up Conversion Paths in Google Analytics (Successfully!)
-
MARKETING7 days ago
(Re)Introducing your favorite Optimizely products!
-
SOCIAL5 days ago
Twitter’s Cancelling Free Access to its API, Which Will Shut Down Hundreds of Apps
-
SEO7 days ago
11 Disadvantages Of ChatGPT Content
-
PPC4 days ago
What the Big Tech Layoffs Mean for SMBs & PPC: 8 Key Takeaways
-
SEO6 days ago
Yelp Details Removal Of Paid Review Groups & Lead Generators