SEO
Former Google CEO Describes ‘Brutal’ Review Process For New Projects

Former Google CEO Eric Schmidt shares details about the “brutal” review process employees had to go through when pitching ideas for new products.
During a Q&A session at the Collision conference in Toronto, Schmidt was asked about his approach to forecasting futures and whether he uses a bottom-up or top-down approach.
Collision is a conference geared toward startups and investors, so the questions asked were all within that realm.
One question prompted Schmidt to drop some interesting tidbits about Google and what it took for employees to get their ideas off the ground while he was CEO.
Google popularized offering time to work on side projects as an employee benefit — known as the 20% Project. Several of those projects became top products like Gmail, AdSense, and Google News.
Schmidt revealed his approach to managing the 20% Project and how it differed from how he explained it while working for Google.
Schmidt On Google’s 20% Project
Responding to the question about forecasting, Schmidt spoke about the approach he and co-founders Larry Page and Sergey Brin took during his time at Google.
Publicly, Schmidt always stated Google took a bottom-up approach to managing the 20% project. Meaning it was a collaborative effort in deciding what steps to take with new product ideas.
However, Schmidt says at Collision that company leaders were more involved than previously stated.
It wasn’t a team decision that allowed projects to advance to the next level. The decision was determined through a “brutal” review process from management.
“When I was running Google, I would always explain how we did it. It was completely bottoms up. You had 20% time where teams could assemble, and people could follow their passion. These were brilliant people, the highest talent.
I would not tell you the rest of the story — and the rest is that Larry [Page], Sergey [Brin], and I would review these things, and these reviews were brutal.
Are these ideas good enough?
Can we fund them?
Are they going to work?
Are they going to scale?
Are they legal?To build a systemic innovation culture, which is what I think we’re talking about here, you need to have both bottoms up and tops down.”
Schmidt explains the benefits of combining bottoms up and tops down decision-making, saying both are needed to succeed in the next 10-20 years.
“The bottoms-up is where the creative ideas come from, and the top-down organizaes and systematizes the decision-making. If you do both, you will win big in the next 10-20 years.
If you do a bit of it, you’ll do OK. You’ll be ‘one of’ the companies. The great companies can invent something and then systematize it, and then regularize it, and then scale it.”
Employee Criticism Of 20% Project
Schmidt’s statement at Collision is in line with what Google employees said about the project in the past.
In 2010, a Google employee published a thread on Quora saying the project was “ineffective” due to the multiple levels of approval needed to launch anything.
“There is a colossal amount of overhead involved in launching anything. The number of approvals (both technical and product) needed for the smallest of launches is overwhelming. For example, you’ll need to have your service live in multiple data centers from day one, because Google has extremely frequent planned maintenance. There are some tools to help you, but you’ve got to do a ton of leg work.”
More About Google’s 20% Project
Google’s 20% Project was in place before the company went public in 2004 and was discontinued in 2013.
A former Google employee blamed the death of the 20% policy on how it was run by management, citing an obsession with efficiency and productivity. Again, that lines up with Schmidt’s statement at Collision.
In 2016, Google revived its concept of 20% project time in the form of the Area 120 incubator. Though it spawned over 50 projects, none reached the same level of success as Gmail and AdSense.
In late 2021, Google reorganized Area 120 under a new division called Google Labs, which houses Google’s AR & VR initiatives as well.
SEO
Bing Chat To Feature Ads, Shaking Up The Ad-Free Experience

Microsoft has announced plans to introduce ads within the AI-powered Bing chat experience.
This is a significant move, as Bing chat has been an ad-free platform up until now.
In a blog post, Microsoft explains why it’s making this change.
Ads In Bing Chat – More Revenue For Publishers?
Since launching the new Bing search experience and Edge browser, Microsoft has aimed to provide an all-in-one experience encompassing search, chat, answers, and content creation.
This strategy is paying off, with over 100 million daily active users on Bing and over 100 million chats recorded.
Interestingly, one-third of the users in the preview are new to Bing, creating an opportunity for publishers.
As Bing chat evolves to better address users’ search needs, questions have arisen about the implications for content publishers.
Microsoft’s goals in this new search landscape include the following:
- Driving more traffic to publishers.
- Increasing revenue for publishers through new features and advertising.
- Fostering a healthy ecosystem through collaboration with the industry.
The early data from the preview suggests Microsoft is on its way to accomplishing these goals.
Unique implementations, such as chat answer citations linked to sources and “learn more” links to additional sources, have helped drive this success.
Exploring New Opportunities For Publishers
Microsoft is actively exploring additional ways to distribute content, positively impacting traffic and revenue.
Some early ideas include:
- Ads in chat: Microsoft is considering placing ads in the chat experience and sharing ad revenue with partners whose content contributed to the chat response.
- An expanded hover experience: Hovering over a publisher’s link will display more links from that publisher, encouraging user engagement and driving more traffic to the publisher’s website.
- Rich captions for Microsoft Start partners: Placing a rich caption of Microsoft Start licensed content beside chat answers can drive user engagement and ad revenue sharing with partners.
Although these discussions are in the early stages, feedback has been positive.
Microsoft plans to continue working directly with publishers to shape the search’s future.
In Summary
The success of Bing’s all-in-one strategy, which combines search, chat, answers, and content creation, is evident in its growing user base.
This growth provides a unique opportunity for publishers to reach new audiences and increase traffic.
As Microsoft continues to explore new opportunities for publishers, such as ads in chat, the potential for increased user engagement and ad revenue sharing becomes more evident.
Although in the early stages, the positive feedback from publishers indicates that these changes could mark a turning point in the future of search and digital advertising.
Source: Microsoft
Featured Image: DANIEL CONSTANTE/Shutterstock
SEO
10 Optimization Tips to Build a Mobile-Friendly Site

A majority of all website visits worldwide are attributed to mobile devices. Optimizing your website for mobile has never been more important in SEO.
In this article, I’ll kick things off by explaining what mobile SEO is and why it’s important. I’ll then get to the core focus of this article, sharing my top 10 tips for effective mobile optimization.
Mobile SEO is the process of optimizing the mobile version of a website to drive organic traffic from search engines. Mobile optimization is focused on providing the best experience on mobile devices where technical implementations, such as using responsive design, play a key role.
According to Statista, mobile devices generated 59% of worldwide mobile traffic in the final quarter of 2022.
It’s not just users that predominantly view your site from a mobile device, but Googlebot too.
In 2016, Google announced mobile-first indexing. As a result, Google predominantly crawls the web via the Googlebot smartphone user agent. This means that Google will primarily use the mobile version of content for indexing and ranking.
Mobile-first indexing began rolling out in 2018. By 2021, a majority of sites moved over to the new format of crawling.
For many years, this was a hot topic among SEO professionals. However, mobile-first indexing is now “part of life,” as put by John Mueller from Google.
So now we know why mobile optimization is so crucial, here are my top 10 tips to ensure you effectively optimize for mobile.
Tip 1. Use responsive design
When it comes to picking your approach to serving content to different devices, you have a few options to choose from.
Responsive design (recommended)
With responsive design, you serve the same HTML file regardless of the device. CSS then alters the rendering of the page to suit the dimensions of the device’s viewport. This also means that you use a singular URL to serve all versions of your content.
Responsive design ensures you can effectively load the same piece of content, oriented to suit your device.

Responsive design is the recommended choice, not just among SEOs but in Google guidance too.
Back in 2019, John took to Reddit to state, “At some point all of these sites with separate mobile URLs should just move to a responsive design.”
Ultimately, there’s no SEO gain by using responsive design. However, it is much easier and cleaner to maintain. For example, you won’t have to worry about canonical issues or Googlebot misunderstanding which URL to serve in the mobile/desktop rankings.
Separate domain/URL structure (not recommended)
An approach used commonly in the past is to serve the mobile version of a page via a separate URL or domain structure. A common example of this is the m. structure.
Desktop: example.com/page
Mobile: m.example.com/page
When a user loads your page, the server will have to determine which device the user is using and then direct them to the appropriate URL.

This approach is not recommended, as using multiple URLs for a single page leads to a messy scenario of URL management.
Even with the correct signals in place, there is the added risk of Googlebot not interpreting these signals appropriately. This can lead to indexation issues or even Google identifying the pages as duplicate content.
If you currently work with this setup, you should ensure you follow the below canonical tag structure.
Desktop: Self-referencing canonical tag
Mobile: Canonical tag to target desktop URL
You’ll also want to implement a rel=”alternate” tag on the desktop version.
<link rel="alternate" media="only screen and (max-width: 640px)" href="https://m.example.com/">
That said, the best solution in the long term is to move to a responsive design setup.
Dynamic serving (not recommended)
Similar to responsive design, with dynamic serving, you’ll be serving content suited to different devices via a singular URL.
However, the main difference with dynamic serving is that you’ll serve different HTML files pre-defined to suit the respective device.

This approach certainly trumps the separate URL/domain structure option, as you have the advantage of serving content to multiple devices via a single URL.
However, dynamic serving is not recommended. History teaches us that this approach is renowned for technical issues.
With dynamic serving, it’s up to your web server to determine which device the user is browsing on. Quite often with dynamic serving setups, the desktop version of the page is accidentally shown to users on a mobile device.
Tip 2. Optimize for page speed on mobile devices
In the era of Core Web Vitals, you could argue that strong page speed performance has never been more sought after by SEO professionals.
In fact, when Google first rolled out Core Web Vitals as a ranking factor in 2021, it focused solely on mobile performance. Google then waited until February 2022 before using desktop Core Web Vital performance as a ranking factor. It’s clear to see which device Google prioritizes.
Google applies mobile and desktop Core Web Vital ranking signals to the respective search results. So for mobile search results, Google will focus on Core Web Vital performance from mobile devices.
A great starting point to see how your site performs against Core Web Vitals is to head to the dedicated report in Google Search Console (GSC). You can navigate to this report via left-hand navigation under the Experience section.

Clicking into the mobile report, you can see how your site has been performing against each Core Web Vital metric over the past three months. This data is gathered via CrUX (Chrome User Experience Report) from real users on your site who used a mobile device.

What’s great about this report in GSC is that the issue URLs are bucketed together into groups of similar pages. This means you can note down a list of key page templates that you need to work on.

For a more detailed insight into issue areas and potential fixes, PageSpeed Insights is always worth a check.
PageSpeed Insights is simple to use. Just enter in the URL of the page you wish to test and hit “enter.” By default, the tool will automatically review the mobile version of your page.

You’ll initially be presented with some insights under the heading “Discover what your real users are experiencing.” This report is the main one I focus on, to start with.
This report utilizes real user data via CrUX. Not only is it important to understand the experience of real users as opposed to bots, but Google also uses this data source within its ranking algorithm.
Here, we can see that Ahrefs’ homepage has passed all three Core Web Vital metrics.

Further down the report, you can also find some actions under the “opportunities” and “diagnostics” sections. These make for some great starting points when having conversations with developers about improving Core Web Vital performance.

When using PageSpeed Insights, don’t forget to test the URLs of multiple page templates within the tool. Page speed performance often varies considerably across different page types.
We’re only scratching the surface here, though. GSC and PageSpeed Insights are only great starting points for auditing page speed.
Check out Patrick Stox’s dedicated guides on page speed and Core Web Vitals to take your page speed knowledge, analysis, and action plan to the next level.
Tip 3. Test and monitor your site for errors
It’s good practice to regularly test your site for key mobile usability errors.
There are multiple tools for this, but a great place to start is via GSC with a dedicated “Mobile Usability” report. You can find this report under the Experience section of the left-hand navigation.
Here, you can keep track of the number of URLs with mobile usability issues. GSC provides a three-month velocity graph. This is handy for identifying spikes in errors, allowing you to correlate them with development releases.

By scrolling down, you can see the exact mobile usability issues that occur on your site. By clicking through to the individual reports, you’ll also be able to see which URLs are affected.

Outside of Search Console, you can also use Google’s Mobile-Friendly Test tool to uncover mobile usability issues.
This is especially useful if you don’t have GSC access to the site you wish to review. Gaining access is recommended though, as you’ll automatically have a wider range of URLs covered.
To use the Mobile-Friendly Test, simply enter the URL (or code) for the page you wish to test to see if your page is deemed as mobile-friendly.
In this case, the tools show that the Ahrefs homepage has passed the test.

On the other hand, if your tested page isn’t mobile-friendly, you’ll be hit with a message saying it’s not usable on mobile with a list of reasons why.

Keen to read more about specific mobile usability issues and how you can address them? Google has some great documentation that goes into more detail.
Tip 4. Make your content mobile-friendly
Making sure your website is optimized for mobile isn’t all about technical foundations. You’ll want to ensure your content is produced with mobile users in mind too.
Many SEOs prefer to use shorter paragraphs and sentences. This aligns nicely with mobile optimization practices.
This approach ensures that your content is readable on mobile devices. Who lands on an article and wants to read a big wall of text? Not me.
As a general guide, aim for a maximum of three sentences per paragraph. If a paragraph naturally just has one sentence, that’s OK too.

When proofing copy drafts, it’s good practice to break long sentences into shorter sentences where possible.
The same rule applies to introductions. In fact, you should apply these rules most strictly here. These should be short, snappy, and to the point.

To further enhance readability, you’ll want to break your copy up by including various elements and media.
These can include:
- Bullet points
- Numbered lists
- Quotes
- Images
- Videos
See what I just did there?
When using different types of media, you’ll want to make sure these display correctly on mobile devices. It’s so frustrating for users when an image loads way out of proportion.
Tip 5. Optimize for mobile SERPs
Mobile SERPs (search engine results pages) can vary quite considerably between the mobile and desktop versions.
When browsing the SERPs for a chosen keyword, it’s important to manually check both the desktop and mobile results.
Here’s an example. Let’s take this wikiHow search result for the query, “how to fry an egg.”
On the desktop search results, we have a pretty standard search result.

On the mobile results, however, we can see that Google has included the how-to images rich result.

SERP estate is crucial. Gaining rich features like in the example above helps your result stand out from the crowd.
This shows how important and relevant schema markup is for mobile optimization. In this example, wikiHow did a nice job by including how-to schema.
Looking to switch device in the search results but don’t want to grab your phone? With Ahrefs’ SEO Toolbar, you can load the results from another device directly in your desktop browser.

Tip 6. Include mobile-friendly navigation
One of the biggest considerations when optimizing your site for mobile devices is the choice of implementation for the header navigation.
This is quite easily one of the most complicated areas of the site to get right for a mobile device.
The hamburger menu has become a popular option in the mobile-first world. It gets its name because the button often looks like a hamburger (apparently).
Here’s an example of the hamburger menu in action on Amazon.

Once you click on the “hamburger” icon, usually located at the very top of the page, the menu will then open out.
In this case, the menu opens out from the left-hand side with options to further expand into navigation subcategories.

Hamburger menus are hotly debated among SEOs and UX professionals. In my opinion, however, you can’t beat the hamburger navigation when it comes to optimizing for mobile.
Not only is this approach clean and compact, but users are also becoming more accustomed to these types of menus on mobile.
It’s OK to go with the “mega menu” approach for your desktop site and switch to the hamburger menu for your mobile site.
The number #1 rule is to ensure that the links within both menus are the same. You’ll want to make sure that you include the exact same links on both your desktop and mobile navigation.
Here, we can see that Apple displays the mega menu on desktop.

And on its mobile site, it uses the hamburger menu but shows the exact same links seen on the desktop version.

For e-commerce websites, faceted navigation is a big consideration too.
Let’s take a look back at Amazon. It has tons of filter options on its product listing pages.
To keep the faceted navigation compact for mobile users, it uses a similar approach to the hamburger menu.

Allowing the faceted navigation to expand on a simple button click keeps your page neat and compact. Perfect for mobile users.
Keen to learn more about site navigation? Be sure to check out Sam Underwood’s article on mastering website navigation.
Tip 7. Keep your content the same
Parity between your site’s mobile and desktop versions is essential. As we mentioned earlier, Google will predominantly crawl the mobile version of your website.
If you were to remove content from the mobile version of your page, you’d run the risk of weakening your content in the eyes of Google.
This rule should be applied to all types of content, from the copy itself to imagery. This rule also applies to technical items, from canonical tags to internal linking.
A great way to test mobile parity is to run a crawl on your mobile site and compare it against a crawl on the desktop version of your site.
Setting up a crawl via Ahrefs’ Site Audit, you have the option to switch between the mobile and desktop user agent.
You can locate this setting under the “Robots instructions” section of the crawl settings.

To test mobile parity via Site Audit, start two separate crawls. One with the user agent set to “AhrefsSiteAudit (Desktop),” and the other with “AhrefsSiteAudit (Mobile).”
You can then compare these crawls in the project history side by side to check for parity between the desktop and mobile crawls.

Notice significantly more errors on the mobile crawl compared to the desktop crawl? This can indicate that your technical elements aren’t being implemented correctly on mobile.
In Site Audit, it’s well worth comparing the HTML source code between your mobile and desktop crawls. This allows you to easily identify any unexpected differences between the mobile and desktop code of your page.
In the example below, we can see that the header menu code has changed between the mobile and desktop crawls. Luckily in this case, this code difference is expected.

You should also consider rendering JavaScript in the crawl settings for websites that heavily rely on that. You can then compare the rendered HTML between the crawls with different user agents. Check our guide to JavaScript SEO for more information.
Tip 8. Avoid intrusive interstitials
Interstitials (also known as pop-ups) that are intrusive and distracting are frustrating for users. This is often an even stronger frustration for mobile users, as pop-ups often take up an even bigger portion of the screen.
Not only could you be decreasing your conversion rate with annoying and intrusive pop-ups, but you’d also get a thumbs-down from Google.
As part of Google’s Page Experience set of ranking signals, Google approves more subtle interstitials as opposed to the large interstitials that cause great frustration.

The big exception to the rule here is that the interstitial may be required by law. Common examples include cookie consent and age gate pop-ups.
For example, on alcohol-related content, the supplier could land in hot water if they didn’t force a user to enter their date of birth before accessing the content.

Tip 9. Review mobile performance
It’s good practice to regularly review the devices that drive your website’s organic traffic.
Starting off with GSC, you can filter by device type in the search performance report.
Simply add a new filter by clicking the “+ new” button above the report and select “Device…”

Here, you can filter your organic performance report via device, allowing you to see just how much organic traffic you’ve acquired via mobile devices. You also have the option to compare traffic by device.

Similar to the “Mobile Usability” report in GSC, it’s worth keeping an eye out for any unexpected fluctuations and traffic drops in mobile traffic. This can be a sign of mobile optimization issues that need further investigation.
You can also view traffic by device in Google Analytics 4. Head to the “Device Category” report by loading Reports > User > Tech > Overview.
Here, you’ll want to click “View platform devices” for the full analytics by device.

You’ll then be presented with data tables, charts, and graphs based on traffic by device type. Don’t forget to add an organic traffic filter to ensure you’re looking purely at “SEO traffic.”

Tip 10. Track rankings on a mobile device
When it comes to tracking keywords, it’s easy to forget that rankings can vary between the desktop and mobile SERPs.
Luckily, switching between desktop and mobile on Ahrefs’ Rank Tracker is simple, making it super easy to see how your site is ranking on either SERP.
What’s also great about Rank Tracker is that you don’t need to specify a device as a setting when you first track your keywords. Keywords are automatically tracked within both the mobile and desktop SERPs.
Simply load your keyword report and switch between mobile and desktop reviews in the top left corner.

Final thoughts
You may be wondering, “Should I just ditch the desktop version of my site and focus on mobile optimization?”
Steady on. It’s true that mobile is now the dominant device, but you won’t want to completely disregard the desktop experience.
Not only will some of your users visit your site via desktop, but Googlebot will also crawl via a desktop user agent from time to time (just not as frequently as the mobile version).
In fact, many websites continue to predominantly drive traffic through users on desktop. This is particularly the case for SaaS companies and many B2B-focused websites in general. For example, the Ahrefs Blog has over 70% of organic traffic coming from users on desktop devices.

To sum it up, the key takeaways are to:
- Show the same content on your mobile site as you would on your desktop site.
- Understand that responsive design is the way to go.
- Prioritize your mobile pages for page speed optimization.
- Not be afraid to use the hamburger menu for mobile devices.
- Regularly monitor and track mobile usability and mobile traffic/rankings.
Have any questions? Ping me on Twitter and let me know.
SEO
Google Search Console Tutorial: Analyzing Traffic Drops

In a YouTube video, Google’s Search Advocate, Daniel Waisberg, offers valuable tips on quickly spotting and analyzing the reasons for a decline in Google Search traffic.
The timing of this informative guide is perfect, as Google just wrapped up its March 2023 core algorithm update. Many people are now evaluating its impact on their websites.
If you’re trying to figure out how the update has affected your site, the Search Console Performance report is an excellent starting point.
Waisberg demonstrates how, when combined with Google Trends, the Search Console Performance report can help you investigate shifts in traffic patterns.
Main Reasons For Organic Traffic Drops
There can be several reasons for a drop in organic traffic. Waisberg highlights these main causes:
- Technical issues: Errors that prevent Google from crawling, indexing, or serving your pages to users. These could be site-level or page-level technical issues.
- Manual actions: If your website doesn’t follow Google’s guidelines, some pages or the entire site may be less visible in Google Search results.
- Algorithm updates: Core updates may change how some pages perform in Google Search over time, leading to a slow decline in traffic.
- Search interest disruption: Changes in user behavior or external influences could affect the demand for certain queries.
- Seasonality effects: Regular traffic fluctuations due to weather, vacations, or holidays.
- Reporting glitches: Sudden major changes followed by a quick return to the norm could indicate a simple glitch.
Analyzing Traffic Drops Using Search Console Performance Report
The Search Console Performance report is an effective tool for understanding traffic fluctuations.
To access the Performance report in Google Search Console, follow these simple steps:
- Log in to the Google Search Console website at search.google.com/search-console.
- Click on the website you want to analyze.
- In the left-hand sidebar menu, click on “Performance.”
You’ll now see the Performance report for your selected property, displaying data such as total clicks, impressions, average click-through rate (CTR), and average position for your website.
Waisberg suggests several ways to analyze the data:
- Expand the date range to 16 months to view the drop in context and identify any patterns or trends.
- Periodically export and store data to access more than 16 months of information.
- Compare the drop period to a similar period (e.g., the same month last year or the same day last week) to pinpoint the exact changes.
- Explore all available tabs to determine if changes occurred only for specific queries, pages, countries, devices, or Search appearances.
- Ensure you compare the same number of days and preferably the same days of the week.
- Analyze different Search types separately to understand if the drop was limited to Search, Google Images, Video, or News tab.
Using Google Trends For Industry Analysis
Google Trends provides insights into web, image, news, shopping, and YouTube search trends.
Waisberg recommends using it to:
- Analyze general trends within your industry or country to identify changes in user behavior or competing products.
- Segment data by country and category for more relevant insights into your website audience.
- Examine queries driving traffic to your site for seasonal fluctuations or trends.
In Summary
Understanding the reasons behind Google Search traffic drops is crucial. Using the Search Console Performance report and Google Trends, you can identify and analyze the causes of these drops, helping you stay ahead of industry trends and maintain your online presence.
In his next video, Waisberg will explore more ways to analyze search performance, including using a bubble chart.
Featured Image: Screenshot from YouTube, March 2023.
Source: YouTube
-
SEO6 days ago
Optimize Your SEO Strategy For Maximum ROI With These 5 Tips
-
SEARCHENGINES7 days ago
Google Search Console Shows If embedURL Page Uses indexifembedded
-
SEARCHENGINES6 days ago
Google Mars Space Office Design At Belo Horizonte, Brazil
-
SEARCHENGINES7 days ago
Google Bard Won’t Link To Sources Too Often
-
SEARCHENGINES6 days ago
Microsoft Advertising Target Shoppers By Browsing Categories With Keyword Boosters
-
SOCIAL5 days ago
LinkedIn Adds New Option to Share a Post with Multiple Members at Once
-
SEO7 days ago
TikTok’s US Future Uncertain: CEO Faces Congress
-
PPC7 days ago
The 7 Best Ecommerce Marketing Channels for New Store Owners